Big White Wall

  • Join now
  • Login
  • The Wall
  • Talkabout
  • Useful stuff
  • Networks
  • How to

Talkabout

You searched for: 
  • child
Go to search results

Subject:

Can you love one child more than the other?

  • 04/03/2008 @ 14:30 HippiChic said:
    HippiChic
    report
    My mother recently told me in a  drunk conversation that she loved me more than my brother. But I have a feeling she has probably said that to him too, except the other way around. It is interesting though because its quite taboo- I'd be interested to hear what any parents have to say on this matter. Can you love one more than the other?
  • 04/03/2008 @ 16:14 Muse said:
    Muse
    report
    I certainly feel that I was loved less than my sister, which is strange because I am the first born and I always felt that if you do love one more... it is more likely to be the first born.  Hippichic, can I ask? Are you the first born?
  • 04/03/2008 @ 18:38 SleeplessKnight said:
    SleeplessKnight
    report
    I think I was loved a bit more than my sister - perhaps love is a bit strong, certainly understood better. I was the second born.. I have heard mums say they 'prefer' one child to the other, I think that happens on and off quite a lot, especially when they hit their teens!
  • 04/03/2008 @ 19:20 sallysue said:
    sallysue
    report
    it always seems to me that my parents loved one child more than the rest. i have 3 siblings and growing up i felt like they always loved someone more than the rest. but i also felt like the person who they loved most changed from time to time. but overall, i feel like the oldest and youngest were most favored... (im the 3rd child) i would like to hear what parents have to say though.
  • 04/03/2008 @ 21:23 Swon said:
    Swon
    report

    Hi HippiChic, long time no speak, good to see you back.

     

    As an only child I never had to worry about that - both of my parents hated me to the same degree (that was a joke).

     

    To answer you question, I suppose it is possible to feel like you love one more than the other but in reality I think what it really is (well is for me) is that I love my two differently.

    They are totally different children (24 and 30 - children??) in that they each have different outlooks, interests, approach to life etc and so I find myself liking different things about them; but equally.

    I hope that makes sense.

     

    Take care

  • 04/03/2008 @ 23:23 el mariachi said:
    el mariachi
    report

    I have a sister and am very fortunate that my parents never showed any favouritism towards one of us or the other. In saying that, my sister is the straight laced one and im the one that mucks up a bit so im sure my mother at times is happier with my sister than me. I guess growing up it was me getting in trouble, I was the adventurous one while my sister was more quiet and homely. I think in some ways its good if you have children that are different from one another and have different interests etc but id like to think that even though I have driven my parents up the wall from time to time and overall, they don't favour one of us over the other.

  • 04/03/2008 @ 23:28 AnxiousZ said:
    AnxiousZ
    report
    I think it depends on the person. I am sure some parents are able to love their children different amounts... but maybe she meant she "liked" you better.
  • 05/03/2008 @ 05:07 johnf said:
    johnf
    report

    My first wife was a great one for stating her belief that all the children of a family should be treated equally and that there should be no scope for any child to wonder if it is loved more of less than any other. All very well in theory, but the facts don't bear the theory out. There is no law of love in nature. There is a biological imperative among mammals (and such are humans) to defend their young until they (the young) become independent. Loving in the context of the family is learned behaviour. You are entitled to love one more than another; you are entitled not to like one or more of your children, but you must, in honour of your having brought them into the world, give them the nurture and protection (and this includes displays of affection) to which they are entitled.

     

    I didn't know the love of my first four until their mother left them with me and headed for greener pastures (and we might discuss the difference between love and lust in that context in some future thread).

     

    When I remarried we had one child of our own, a wonderful daughter, the product of a love everybody should experience at least once (once is sufficient in our case). I am very close to her and you could probably say that I do love her more than I love the others. But I love all of them, and these days I like all of them as well, although this hasn't always been the case. That probably doesn't help, but...

  • 05/03/2008 @ 06:52 UMxx said:
    UMxx
    report

    This is hard work - but I reckon this is what I feel.

     I love both of my children - I can't say I love one more than the other - but each is such an individual and because of this there are aspects of each that I completely "get" and others that I just feel must have originated from some alien gene pool. 

    I love different aspects of their personality and enjoy having separate time with them but don't think I could ever say I love one more than the other.

    This is about me and I must say how relieved just how much I find myself feeling about all this -  I was told that I was much more lovable than one of my siblings throughout my childhood and felt uncomfortable about this.  I loved my sibling and thought it was pretty lousy that I was told this.  Now I realise that I had one very manipulative parent who was doing this to make my sibling work harder for approval and for me to have a closer relationship.  Well I was a weird kid in lots of ways and just felt that my parents were a bit troppo and didn't really have much of a clue.  Maybe I am the way I am because it is something that I reckon is important as a parent or maybe I am just plain lucky - don't know.

  • 05/03/2008 @ 14:00 HippiChic said:
    HippiChic
    report

    Hey everyone, and thank you for replying to my post. It did feel weird Unionmade when my mother said this, but she has a manipulative streak in her too, especially after a drink, and she had also just been complaining that she never sees my brother much, so I wouldn't be surprised if she says the same to him when I am out of her favour.

    Muse I am the second born, althouh I can see your thinking! But I guess if we were compared I am a bit more relaxed and outthere than my brother, who is a quieter gentler soul. We are both musicians though, which is something we share.

    S1, thank you - its nice to be back :) Good to see you too

    Its interesting getting the male (father) and female(mother) perspective on this also, I know my dad is closer to my brother because he understands him more, he doesn't get me with all my pink clothes and silly ways.. we never really connected, I wonder if there is less to 'get' in one child, and more in another, then you can love one more than the other?

    hmmm 

  • 05/03/2008 @ 15:21 aenea said:
    aenea
    report
    Even though I always felt that my parents loved my brother more (wahhh me), now that I've got my own kids it just seems that I love them differently.  There are definitely days when I might like one child more, but so far it seems to rotate fairly evenly between them.  And they've all got such neat strengths of their own that I can't imagine having to "pick" one that I love more. 
  • 05/03/2008 @ 15:44 zorro said:
    zorro
    report
    My sister and I were so different that my mother used to get really irate when people compared us (usually at school, teachers saying I was bad, she was good!). Although we both am sure brought her seperate challenges and joys, she always made it known that we were both individuals first and sisters second and that that was a good thing.

Top »

Post reply

You need to login to add your own comments

Related tags

  1. child
  2. love
  3. more
  4. other
View more talkabout tags »

Related bricks

Thank you
  • Previous
  • Pause
  • Next
abmsemBrick viewer

Useful stuff

  • Name your fears to improve your emotional health
    Name your fears to improve your emotional health
    Big White Waller, Jomo, uses the therapy she has received and the help she has been given to look at how we can learn to control our fears by...
View more usefulstuff »
  • © 2007-2008 BigWhiteWall Limited
  • About us
  • Terms of use
  • Your privacy
  • House rules
  • How to...
  • Contact Us